Red Dead Redemption 2: Mastering the Game’s Fist Fighting System

Red Dead Redemption 2 has a vast arsenal of weapons for players to find and master. However, sometimes the best weapons for the job are your own two hands. If you want to pick a few fist fights in Rockstar’s ambitious sequel, this guide can show you the ropes of how to fist fight in Red Dead Redemption 2. Better yet, following the advice we outline should ensure you win any fist fights you get into.

Red Dead Redemption 2's fist fighting system takes a little effort to master.

Red Dead Redemption 2 Fist Fighting Mastery

An obvious first step is to ensure you don’t have a weapon equipped. You can do this by opening up your weapon wheel and highlighting the hand symbol on the right. With your fists set as your equipped weapon, the following controls are used in combat depending on your respective console:

Xbox One

  • Punch: B
  • Grapple: Y
  • Block: X
  • Break Free: Tap B

PlayStation 4

  • Punch: Circle
  • Grapple: Triangle
  • Block: Square
  • Break Free: Tap Circle

How to Win a Fist Fight in Red Dead Redemption 2

Going in fists flying is certainly one strategy, but it’s not the most effective one. Instead, focus more on punishing your opponent’s mistakes. Let them throw a few punches and block them as needed. When you see an opening, counter-punch and use Grapples if your opponent tries to block. If your opponent attempts to grab you, break free by tapping the punch button. This strategy should help you triumph over any would-be brawlers who cross you. Just note that fist fighting isn’t the most wholesome activity so try to do it out sight from law enforcement.

For more Red Dead Redemption 2 guide content, you can check out how to unlock fast travel. We also covered how to reliably get clean kills while hunting the game’s wildlife.