I also had PlayStation and together with my brothers we've changed a bunch of controllers. Before we got bored with them, they simply broke)) no reaction from buttons or wrong actions, or no signal at all. We used to spend days in front of the TV screen playing one by one, the attack on the controller mechanics was cruel)))
Now I play on PC and also use a gamepad, its the most simple, black and dull. I'm waiting for the insight when I definitely feel the need to change it))